Direct Mail (Fundraising) Is Not Dead

by | May 1, 2024

It’s Still the King of Fundraising ROI

Myth: Direct mail is a relic of the past, overshadowed by flashy digital fundraising campaigns.

Fact: Direct mail is still alive and thriving—and remains the core driver for fundraising results.

According to the Association of National Advertisers, direct mail boasts the highest average response rate among all platforms—an impressive 5.3%. Compare that to a mere 0.1% for email, 0.6% for paid search, and 0.2% for online display marketing. The numbers speak for themselves—direct mail delivers results.

Here’s why you should always embrace this timeless strategy in your fundraising efforts.

Advantages of Direct Mail for Fundraising

So, what makes direct mail so effective? Let’s break it down:

  • Tangible: A physical piece of mail engages the senses in a way that digital communication simply can’t match.
  • Personalization: With variable data, you can tailor your message to each donor, making them feel genuinely valued.
  • Standing Out: In a digital world oversaturated with content, direct mail cuts through the noise and demands attention.
  • Less Disruptive: Your audience can read direct mail as and when they want without getting disturbed by pop-ups or incoming email messages.
  • Emotional Connection: Direct mail evokes emotions and makes donors feel special, fostering stronger connections to your cause.
  • Longevity: Direct mail can linger in homes and offices, serving as a constant reminder of your mission.
  • Trackable Results: Direct mail allows you to track responses and measure the effectiveness of your campaign with precision.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Direct mail can be surprisingly cost-effective, especially when you work with an agency like Graphcom that can analyze your list and target only the folks most likely to become donors.
  • Good for Stewardship: Direct mail isn’t just for acquiring new donors—it’s also an essential tool for stewardship and nurturing existing relationships.
  • Trust and Credibility: Studies show that direct mail is perceived as more trustworthy than digital channels, enhancing your credibility with donors.
  • Higher Open Rates: Direct mail consistently boasts higher open rates than email and other digital channels.
  • Endless Creativity: From eye-catching design to compelling content, the possibilities for creativity are limitless.
  • Familiar: It’s important to meet donors where they’re most comfortable. The average age of a U.S. donor is 64. This generation is filled with late adopters most familiar with direct mail giving. More than half of Baby Boomer donors say direct mail is somewhat likely or very likely to influence them to give.

Best Practices for Fundraising Success

While direct mail should remain the foundation of your fundraising campaign, you can’t ignore the power of digital channels.

Digital may not produce the same results as direct mail, but it does boost response rates to direct mail. The United States Postal Service found that coordinating digital with direct mail increases response rates by 63%, website visits by 68%, and leads by 53%. Just think of how often you’ve received a piece of mail and forgot to respond until you received a follow-up email.

A comprehensive multichannel approach—incorporating direct mail, email, landing pages, text, social media, and more—is key to maximizing your reach and impact. To maximize the effectiveness of your fundraising campaigns, consider these additional best practices:

  • Know Your Audience: Understand your donors’ preferences, motivations, and values to tailor your message effectively. Meet them on the channels they’re most comfortable with.
  • Embrace Storytelling: Connect with donors on an emotional level by sharing compelling stories that resonate with your cause.
  • Set Clear Goals: Define measurable objectives and track your progress to ensure you’re on the path to success.
  • Combine Digital and Print: Integrate online elements into your direct mail campaigns (i.e., a QR code to your online donation form or a video from your nonprofit president thanking donors) to enhance engagement and response rates.
  • Follow-Up: Show appreciation for donors’ support with timely follow-up communications, fostering long-term relationships.
  • Work Smarter: Apply your data findings from testing and tracking results to future campaigns to improve your response rates and lower your cost per piece.

The message is clear: don’t overlook direct mail in your next fundraising campaign. Partnering with a fundraising marketing agency like Graphcom can take your direct mail efforts to the next level. With our expertise and insights, you can create smarter, more targeted campaigns that resonate with donors and drive results.

Embrace the power of print and watch your donations soar. And remember, a well-thought-out multichannel approach is the key to success.

Maximize Donor Engagement

Unlock fundraising success—check out these direct mail fundraising campaigns that delivered results for our clients.
Share This